Get the free State of the Beef Industry report. Download Now. 

January 9, 2023

Programmatic vs. Endemic Advertising: Which Is More Effective?

Our clients in the agriculture industry ask this question more and more frequently. They want to know which approach to use to get the most bang for their bucks. The answer: programmatic and endemic advertising can work together. It’s not a matter of either/or.

Endemic advertising focuses on placing ads in media that is relevant to the content. Using this approach, your ag-related ad would appear on ag-related sites. For example, at Farm Journal, we offer endemic advertising on the industry’s leading agriculture sites, such as AgWeb, Drovers, The Scoop and Dairy Herd.

Programmatic advertising, on the other hand, is the automatic buying and selling of ad space in real-time on tens of thousands of websites and apps. Programmatic campaigns driven by first-party data don’t wait for your audience to visit a specific endemic property. Instead, it places an ad instantaneously as soon as your audience visits a site, whether or not it’s contextually related to your message. In other words, rather than hoping your target viewers see your ad, programmatic advertising finds the viewers where they are.

A Matter of Value

An endemic approach lets you choose sites that are relevant to your ag audience, perhaps one they subscribe to or visit regularly offering content about farming or ranching. Your ad for an ag-related product or service makes sense within the context of these sites. The audience expects to see them there.

This approach has obvious value, but what about the farmers who don’t visit the endemic site? How are you reaching them? How many of them are you missing?

Flexibility First

Farm Journal executed programmatic ads reach a first-party audience wherever they go online. Your ad isn’t just waiting for them to visit the ag-related site you’ve chosen. Instead, it’s meeting them wherever they visit online, which is especially important when trying to maximize reach a niche audience.

Using programmatic advertising also opens up significantly more ad space options. You’re not restricting your campaign to just the endemic sites that seem to be most relevant to your audience. You can, however, define the range of sites you want to include. At Farm Journal, we run programmatic ads to brand-safe online properties that includes news, weather, sports and business websites and apps. Our programmatic ads can reach more than 90% of farmers in your target audience segment. While endemic properties are, without question, very valuable to agri-marketers, none offer an opportunity this comprehensive in terms of reach and frequency.

Find the Right Mix

So, you can see that endemic and programmatic advertising are able to work together to reach your target audience, each offering certain capabilities. It’s not a question of one or the other but, instead, how best to allocate your budget to get the results you want. While agri-marketers are probably more accustomed to endemic advertising, they should also consider increasing the percentage of programmatic ads they buy to increase their ROI.

Why? At Farm Journal, we surveyed 38 agri-marketing professionals and found that, on average, they allocate only 25.4% for programmatic advertising. Meanwhile, a recent survey of 100 farmers conducted by Farm Journal revealed that they spend 63% of their online time on non-ag platforms. Programmatic ads enable agri-marketers to deliver their message where farmers and ranchers spend 2/3 of their time digitally.

As agri-marketers, we have an opportunity to get that bigger bang for our buck by allocating an appropriate amount of our budget to programmatic advertising. By finding the right balance, we’ll be more successful in optimizing return on ad spend.

Breakthrough marketing and sales start with deep understanding. Learn how our Intelligence and Influence Solutions can drive smarter strategies: https://www.farmjournal.com/solutions/#Intelligence

Share to your audience

It’s not a question of one or the other but, instead, how best to allocate your budget to get the results you want.

Additional Resources

The Three Market Forces Reshaping Agriculture Sales and Marketing

Agriculture is in one of its most consequential periods in decades. Today’s farm economy is under prolonged financial strain that is reshaping how growers make decisions, a moment economists describe as “not a collapse, but a grind.”

Your Next Big Customer Isn’t Guesswork. Clues Are in the Data

Most machinery dealers are sitting on a mountain of customer data, but still can’t answer the questions that actually move iron: Who’s growing, who’s slowing, and what are they shopping for right now?

Digital Media Summit 2025: Shifting Strategies in a Changing Digital Landscape

Insights from a gathering of Digital Practitioners